In addition to the cost-benefit constraint, two other constraints include:

Update

Table of Contents

Accounting constraints are those that constrain us from reporting certain things on the financial statements. There are two main constraints that would allow us to not report information that we would otherwise report on the statements. 

• Materiality Constraint, and
• Benefit Constraint

Back to: Accounting & Taxation

What is the Materiality Constraint?

The materiality constraint states that only information that would influence a decision of a reasonable person needs to be disclosed. 

For example, let's say that I reported 50 million dollars in accounts receivable. It then realize that my statement is off by approximately 1 thousand dollars. Would that discrepancy cause me to restate the financial statements? Probably not, as $1k is material in relation to $50m. It would not change somebody else's decision on whether to invest in me or not.

The same example, but I added a few extra zeros and it's only $50,000 in accounts receivable. That would definitely be material. I need to restate that to accurately reflect the position of the firm, as this information is really going to change a reasonable person's decision on whether they're going to invest in me.

What is the Benefit Constraint? 

The benefit constraint states that only information with benefits of disclosure greater than the cost of providing it need to be disclosed. Basically, you only disclose things that provide a greater value to the recipient than it costs to make the disclosure. 

The important point here is that it costs a great deal of money and effort to identify, organize, and disclose certain information. If the costs of undertaking this effort outweigh benefits to those for whom the disclosure is intended, then disclosure (and all the tasks necessary to bring about disclosure) are not necessary. 

The constraints of accounting refer to the limitations to providing financial information. Financial reporting must follow generally accepted accounting principles, or GAAP. The constraints of accounting permit certain variations from the basic accounting principles in reporting a company's financial information. Such variations are not considered a violation of the GAAP because of the recognized constraints of accounting.

Costs and Benefits

One major constraint of accounting is the costs of providing financial information. Financial reporting is not cost free because companies must spend time and money to collect, process, analyze and disseminate relevant information. In deciding what to include in a financial reporting, companies must weigh the costs of providing particular information against the benefits that can be derived from using the information. Therefore, companies may not require particular accounting measurements or disclosures if the costs of implementing them exceed the benefits accrued to users of the information.

Video of the Day

Materiality

While the cost-benefit constraint of accounting may limit the scope of the financial information provided in an effort to control reporting costs, the materiality constraint allows companies to omit certain information that is immaterial and won't have an impact or influence on information users. In other words, companies must include all information that has a material impact on their overall financial performance. Companies determine the materiality of information based on its relative size and importance. When the amount involved is relatively small or the nature of the information at issue is unimportant, companies may resort to the materiality constraint not to report the information.

Industry Practices

While cost-benefit and materiality are the two overriding accounting constraints, industry practices are a less dominant constraint but also part of the reporting environment. Particular industry practices in financial reporting may cause departure from basic accounting standards for companies in certain industries. For example, contrary to recording asset value at historical cost as required by GAAP, companies in the agricultural business may report corps at their market value because it's difficult to estimate original corps cost. The constraint of industry practices allows companies to deviate from some prescribed reporting standards on certain financial information.

Conservatism

Similar to industry practices, conservatism is another less prevalent accounting constraint but should be observed in financial reporting when applicable. Conservatism means that when in doubt about how to report an accounting issue, choose the method that least likely overstates assets and income or understates liabilities and losses. Sometimes companies may find difficult situations in which simply following GAAP may not yield the best reporting results. For example, GAAP doesn't require the accrual of losses on a likely future purchase of inventories, but if the planned purchase is a firm commitment, it's conservative to accrue the losses now from any future price increases.

What are the two constraints in financial reporting?

What are the 4 types of constraints under accounting convention?

What is the cost benefit constraint?

What is an example of a cost constraint?